Renata's desires - Part 3

Renata does the worst thing that she never mustn't do: she strikes back. Dr. Lomp won't let her with this fault. He starts to whip her back, while she hopes a pillow to reduce whip affect. Then a moment, she captures the shocker to defend herself. Dr. Lomp with a single tail whip, poor girl Renata with a shocker. Who is supposed to be the winner of this challenge?