My wife knows how much i love a creampie, when she is getting fucked by other men she always begs them to spunk up her, sometimes in threesomes sometimes when a stranger has fucked her on her nights out, she has bought me back many many creampies, there is no feeling like it.
I've been lucky enough to do this many times but it has never been anything to do with "reclaiming". Having just watched my wife/girlfriend fuck a stranger in front of me, I'm incredibly turned on. When the guest has finished, I want my turn. Eat the pie or fuck the pie, the order doesn't matter, I just do it while it's fresh. Savour the flavour or feel her silk lined cunt welcoming your cock. Cherish your precious partner.